The Utility of Plasma Transthyretin and
Antioxidants as aBiomarker of Early Pregnancy Loss - A Pilot Study
Sen
M.1, Goenka L.2, Jha D.3, Raj V.4,
Charles S.5, Mala K.6, George M.7
1Dr.
Maitrayee Sen, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 2Ms. Luxitaa
Goenka, Department of Clinical Pharmacology, 3Ms.Durga Jha,
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, 4Mr.Vijay Raj, Department of
Medical Research, 5Ms. Soniya Charles, Department of Biotechnology, 6Dr.
Kanchana Mala, Department of Medical Research, 7Dr. Melvin George,
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, all authors are affiliated with SRM MCH
& RC, Kattankulathur, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India.
Corresponding
Author: Dr. Melvin George, Department of
Clinical Pharmacology, SRM MCH & RC, Kattankulathur, Chennai, Tamil Nadu,
India. E-mail:melvingeorge2003@gmail.com
Abstract
Objective:
Miscarriage or early pregnancy loss
(EPL) affects about 15-25% of all pregnancies and is considered as one of the
most common complications of the human reproduction. The objective of this
pilot study was to quantify and compare the levels of plasma Transthyretin (TTR)
and total antioxidant capacity (TAC)among EPL patients and normal pregnant
women. Design: Cross sectional pilot
study. Subjects: Patients diagnosed
with EPL in their first trimester (Incomplete and Missed abortion) and
medically terminated pregnancy (MTP) and pregnant women in their first
trimester of pregnancy without any complications. Methods: Plasma TTR and total antioxidantcapacity were quantified
using Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) and Trolox equivalent
antioxidant capacity assay respectively. Statistical analyses were performed
with SPSS software version 16.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). All p values <0.05
were considered statisticallysignificant. Results:A
total of 60 subjects were enrolled in the study. There was no significant
difference in the mean concentration of plasma TTR among women with EPL
322.20(187.33-444.10) µg/ml and normal pregnant women 224.32(176.06-509.97)
µg/ml (p=0.501). However, a significant difference was observed in the TACamong
women with EPL 0.58 (0.51-0.70) mM/μl and normal pregnant women 0.71
(0.63-0.79) mM/μl (p=0.006). No significant correlation was seen between TTR
and antioxidant capacity. Conclusion: Our
study failed to demonstrate any relationship between plasma TTR levels and EPL.
Antioxidant capacity was lower among EPL patients suggesting the importance of
supplementation with antioxidants to prevent poor outcomes in pregnancy.
Keywords:
Early pregnancy loss, Transthyretin, Antioxidants
Author Corrected: 23th February 2019 Accepted for Publication: 1st March 2019
Introduction
Miscarriage or early
pregnancy loss (EPL) affects about 15-25% of all pregnancies, and is considered
as one of the most common complication of the human reproduction. The most common
etiologies of EPL include the genetic or chromosomal abnormalities in the
developing embryo, endocrine diseases, immunological factors, chemical agents,
hereditary disorders, and psychological factors.Oxidative stress which is defined
as an imbalance between pro-oxidants and antioxidant capacityhas been
implicated in many reproductive and pregnancy disorders such as sub fertility
to miscarriage, maternal vascular disease and preterm labour [1]. Burton and
Jauniax et al. suggested that there was an increase in the oxidative stress
markers in placenta tissue among EPL patients when compared to controls. This
indicated an increase in the reactive oxygen species (ROS) which was due to
premature establishment of maternal perfusion.Thus, the increase in oxidative
stress may be associated with EPL [2]. Transthyretin (TTR), a 56-kDa
homotetrameric protein, belongs to a group of proteins including
thyroxine-binding globulin and albumin which is mainly synthesized in the liver,
eye and choroid plexus. TTR is down regulated in the placental villous
trophoblasts of early pregnancy loss in human. TTR plays a critical role in the
transportation of the thyroid hormone, thyroxin (T4) in the blood and retinol
through an association with retinol binding protein (RBP); which are both critical
for the neurological development of the fetus [3]. The secretion of TTR from
the placenta is known to play a vital role in the transportation of the
maternal thyroid hormone to the fetal circulation through the formation of the
TTR-T4 complex.The formation of this complex protein TTR-T4 is considered
important for the normal development of the fetus [4, 5]. It has been observed
that the fetus begins to secrete thyroid hormone only after 12 weeks of gestation
and until this time the fetal thyroid hormone supply originates from the mother
and this is thought to continue throughout the pregnancy period. The perseverance
of high levels of deiodinase type 3 activity in the placenta is thought to inactivate
T4 to its inactive form rT3. The existence of placental TTR
in the 6th week of gestation will aid in the binding maternal T4,
which in turn will prevent deiodination and its delivery to fetal capillaries [6].
Down regulation of TTR
during the first trimester pregnancy may lead to fetal growth restriction and development
of pre-eclampsia [7-9]. Therefore, we hypothesized that the plasma levels of
TTR might be low in EPL, suggesting thatTTR might be used as asuitable
diagnostic marker for EPL and a potential therapeutic target in preventing
subsequent miscarriage.The deficiencies in the antioxidant activities might
result in poor pregnancy outcomes such as fetal growth restriction and preeclampsia
[10]. Therefore, the measurement of plasma antioxidants can be a suitable
diagnostic novel marker for EPL. Hence, we also attempted to measure the
antioxidant concentration among study subjects. Therefore, the objective of our
study was to quantify the levels of plasma TTR andtotalantioxidant capacity
among patients with EPL and patients with normal pregnancy.
Methods
Study
Population, type of study and ethical consideration:This
was a cross-sectional pilot study performed in the Department of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology and Clinical Pharmacology of a tertiary care hospital between
January and August 2017. The study was approved by the institutional ethics
committee. Thy study was Compliant with the Ethical Requirements. The study
involved human participants. The Informed Consent Informed consent was obtained
from all individual participants included in this study.
Inclusion
and exclusion criteria: Patients were diagnosed
with EPL in their first trimester (Incomplete and Missed abortion) were
considered eligible for inclusion into the study as cases. Patients who visited
the outpatient department for medically terminated
pregnancy (MTP) and pregnant women in their first trimester of pregnancy
without any complications were considered eligible for inclusion as normal
controls (NCs). We excluded patients with baseline hypertension, proteinuria,
renal disease, diabetes, and twin pregnancy. Other exclusion criteria included
patients with any major or minor fetal anomaly and chromosomal abnormalities.
Clinical
collection of data: Clinical and
demographic data were collected on patient age, waist and hip circumference,
body mass index (BMI), gestational weeks and last menstrual period (LMP). Data
were also collected on other risk factors such as consumption of coffee and use
of oral contraceptives (OCPs).Blood sampling was done to determine the level of
hemoglobin (Hb), serum creatinine (SCr), blood urea and platelet count.
Laboratory
Investigations
Enzyme
Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA): After
obtaining the written informed consent from all patients, 4 ml of blood sample
was collected from the ante-cubital vein in the forearm. After adequate
centrifugation at 2500 revolutions per minute (rpm) for 10 minutes, the plasma samples
were extracted and were stored in −80°C deep freezer. The plasma which was
centrifuged from the blood sample was subjected to competitive enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the measurement of protein TTR. The assay was performed
according to the manufacturer’s instructions provided inthe commercially
available Human Transthyretin ELISA Kit (Bioassay Technology Laboratory, Cat.
No E0000Hu, Shanghai, China). Inter and intra-assay coefficient of variation
(CV’s) was 6% and 8%, respectively. The measurement of TTR was done in a
blinded fashion as the investigators who performed the ELISA assay were not
informed about the patient’s diagnosis.
Antioxidant
assay: Plasma antioxidant capacity was measured
by TEAC (Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity) assay. It was performed
according to the manufacturer’s recommendations as provided in the commercially
available kit (Antioxidant Assay kit, Sigma-Aldrich, Missouri, USA). The assay
is based on scavenging of ABTS+ which is produced from oxidization of ABTS
[2,2′-Azino-bis(3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulfonic acid)]. Antioxidants available
in the plasma sample derived from patient’s blood sample neutralize the radical
cation, ABTS+ in a concentration dependent manner. Since ABTS+ is a chromogenic
compound, the colour intensity was determined by spectrophotometer at 405 nm
(Infinite F50 ELISA Plate Reader, Tecan Group Ltd, Mannedorf, Switzerland). It
utilizes Trolox, a synthetic water-soluble antioxidant analogous to Vitamin E,
which is used to express standard and samples as Trolox equivalent (mM) based
on a Trolox standard curve. Inter and intra-assay CV’s were 7% and 8%,
respectively. The lab measurements were done in a blinded fashion as the
investigators who performed the assay were unaware about the patient’s
diagnosis.
Statistical
Analysis: The normality of data for continuous
variables was checked using Q-Q plot in SPSS. Continuous variables were
summarized as mean ± standard deviation (SD) or median (IQR) and categorical
data were expressed as frequency and percentages. Differences in the
categorical variables between groups were evaluated using the chi-square test. Parametric
or non-parametric tests wereused based on the distribution of data. The differences
in continuous variables between groups were analyzed with Mann-Whitney U test
or Independent Sample t Test based on normality of data. Spearman and Pearson
correlation was done to establish the relation between the laboratory assays. All
statistical analyses were performed with SPSS software version 16.0 (SPSS Inc.,
Chicago, IL). All p values <0.05 were considered statisticallysignificant.
Results
A total of 60 subjects
were enrolled in the study. The study participants comprised of two groups: patients
withmissed/incomplete abortion (n=30) and controls comprised ofpatients with uncomplicated
pregnancy (n=30).Allinformation on the baseline demographic data, clinical
variables, laboratory investigations and risk factors were collected (Table1). There
were no significant differences in the baseline demographic and clinical
variables between the two groups. Significant differences were not observed in
the laboratory investigations, platelet count, blood urea and serum creatinine
between thetwo groups.
Table-1:
Baseline Characteristics Including Demographics, Risk Factors and Laboratory
findings of Study Patients
Patient Characteristics |
Missed
Abortion/Incomplete Abortion (n=30) |
Uncomplicated/Normal
Pregnancy (n=30) |
p-value |
Age,
years |
25.33±3.94 |
24.93±3.80 |
0.285 |
BMI,
kg/m2 |
22.91±4.73 |
24.85±3.68 |
0.186 |
Systolic
Blood Pressure, mm Hg |
111.72±5.31 |
110.41±9.40 |
0.808 |
Diastolic
Blood Pressure, mm Hg |
72.33±8.98 |
73.05±8.30 |
0.783 |
Heart
Rate, PR |
81.63±5.01 |
79.55±6.73 |
0.214 |
No.
of gestational weeks |
9.56±3.02 |
8.96±3.49 |
0.508 |
Platelet
count, per cu mm |
282840±53434.6 |
228760±97411.2 |
0.067 |
Blood
urea, mg/dL |
15.28±5.76 |
15.50±3.16 |
0.919 |
Serum
creatinine, mg/dL |
0.49±0.12 |
0.5±0.05 |
0.780 |
Coffee
Intake (Yes/No) |
2(6.7%) |
7(23.3%) |
0.070 |
Use of Oral Contraceptives (Yes/No) |
2(6.7%) |
3(10%) |
0.316 |
There
was no significant difference in the median concentration of plasma TTR among patients
with missed/incomplete abortion and controls [322.20 (187.33-444.10) µg/mlversus
224.32 (176.06-509.97) µg/ml (p=0.501)] respectively (Figure 1a). However, a
significant difference was observed in themedian total antioxidant capacityamong
patients with missed/incomplete abortion and controls[0.58 (0.51-0.70) mM/μl
versus0.71 (0.63-0.79) mM/μl (p=0.006)] respectively (Figure 1b). No significant
correlation was observed between plasma TTR and antioxidant capacity.
Furthermore, no significant correlation was observed between gestational weeks,
and antioxidant capacity and gestational weeks respectively.
Discussion
To the best of our
knowledge this is the first clinical study that studied and compared the plasma
levels of TTR among women with EPL and uncomplicated pregnancy. The present
study compared the levels of TTR among women with EPL and uncomplicated
pregnancy. There are only few clinical studies that measured the plasma levels
of TTR among pregnant women in their first trimester. However, most of these
studies were performed among pregnant women with preeclampsia [9, 11-12]. The
TTR levels observed in our study (224.32 µg/ml) were in consensus with the
study performed by Fruscalzo et al (211 µg/ml) [9].
The present study
failed to demonstrate any significant difference in the plasma levels of TTR among
women with EPL and women without any complications in their pregnancies. Ourstudy
results did not match the results of the study which was performed by Liu et
al. and colleagues,where proteomic analysis on the alteration of protein
expression in the placental villous tissue of EPL was done. The study revealed
that there were reasonable decreases in the grade of TTR protein staining in
the cytoplasm of syncytiotrophoblastic and/or cytotrophoblastic cells in
placental villous tissues obtained from the EPL group compared to women with
uncomplicated pregnancy [13]. Although in a study performed by Episkopou et al.
TTR deficient mice reported normal fertility, some of the recent studies
reported that the protein might play an important role in the early stages of
pregnancy [14]. The down regulation of TTR, a protein involved in the vitamin A
and thyroid hormone metabolism may play a vital role in the pathological
development of EPL.However, studies have reported that the progesterone
receptor plays a role in the up regulation and synthesis of TTR, secretion and
uptake of TTR by human placenta have also been reported. Recent studies have
reported the internalization of TTR by trophoblast and in the presence of T4,
there is an increase in the uptake of TTR [4, 15-16]. Therefore, in consensus
with our study it may be hypothesized that an increase in the plasma levels of
TTR among women with EPL than in women with uncomplicated pregnancy can be
explained by the theory of decreased internalization of TTR by trophoblasts. In
EPL there is deficiency of progesterone as well as deficiency of T4 in the maternal
circulation which may prevent the internalization of TTR and thus increase the
serum level of TTR and simultaneously decrease the local TTR at placental
villous tissue [17, 18]. Furthermore, clinical studies measuring TTR levels
were performed among pregnant women with preeclampsia.The studies showed that TTR
levels were lower among women with severe preeclampsia in each month of
gestation than among women with normal pregnancy [9, 11-12]. Therefore, the production
of TTR by trophoblasts demonstrateda mechanism that helps in the transfer of
maternal thyroid hormone to the fetal circulation which could have clinical
implications in the fetal development [6].
Our study showed that
the totalantioxidant capacity was significantly higher among women with
uncomplicated pregnancy when compared to women with EPL. Similar results were
seen in other studies where the antioxidant capacity was lower among women who
had a first trimester miscarriage than that of healthy women in their first
trimester pregnancy [19]. The total antioxidant status (TAS) and copper (Cu)
was significantly lower among women who experienced EPL than that of the normal
pregnant women.In another study performed by Jenkins et al., it was observed
that women suffering from EPL had significantly lower levels of antioxidants superoxide
dismutase (SOD) when compared to women whose pregnancies were successful [20]. During
the first trimester pregnancy, the abnormal placentation would cause oxidative
stress that result in the endothelial dysfunction. This would lead to the
emergence of pregnancy complications such as abortion [21]. The excess
production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) will lead to the cellular damage of
DNA, lipids and cellular proteins.The supplementation of antioxidants can
protect the cells from peroxidation reactions that can prevent cellular damage
and can also help in the maintenance of cellular integrity [22]. Furthermore,
studies have also shown that oxidative stress is associated with recurrent
pregnancy losses [23-25]. Therefore, measuring the antioxidant levels might be
considered as a novel diagnostic marker for EPL and supplementation with adequate
antioxidants might provide a substantial therapeutic benefit.
We also attempted to
study the relationship between TTR and gestational weeks among the study
patients. However, our study failed to produce any correlation between
gestational age and TTR. In a study, the changes in placental TTR in early and
late pregnancy was measured where placentas were collected from the surgically
terminated pregnancies between 6 and 17 weeks of gestation and compared with
the normal term between 38 to 39 weeks following the caesarean section. The
laboratory methods used for deterring the TTR mRNA and protein levels were Real
time-Polymerase Chain Reaction, western blotting and immunohistochemistry. The
study demonstrated a significant increase in the expression of TTR mRNA and TTR
proteins between 6th and 13th weeks of gestation; however,
this increase in expression was not seen between 13th and17thweeks
[26]. Our study being limited to women in their first trimester of pregnancy
(<12 weeks) may be one of the reasons for the failure to produce any
significant correlation between TTR and gestational weeks. During the first
trimester of pregnancy the placenta remains relatively hypoxic and there will
be an increase in the oxygen level to an average of about 2.5% at 8 weeks and
8.5% at 12 weeks which remains stable until delivery [27, 28]. The increase in
the levels of oxygen leads to the production of TTR in JEG-3 human
choriocarcinoma cells. Therefore, it has been hypothesized that the production
of TTR is increased during the first trimester pregnancy and the expression
remains constant throughout the gestation [29]. Our study is a preliminary,
pilot study with a small sample size and the samples being collected at
different points of time during first trimester. Due to logistic reasons, we did
not measure the mRNA expression of TTR among the study patients from the
products of conception, an indirect method of estimation of TTR locally at
placental tissue.
Our study failed to
demonstrate any relationship between plasma TTR levels and early pregnancy loss.
Antioxidant capacity was lower among EPL patients suggesting the importance of
supplementation with antioxidants to prevent poor outcomes in pregnancy. Future
studies should be directed towards understanding the role of transthyretin in
early pregnancy loss using a larger cohort of subjects.
Source
of funding &Acknowledgments:The project was
funded by SRM Institute of Science and Technology (SRMIST) under Grant
[SRMIST-SEI-2016-04-095]. We would also like to thank Ms. Masum Sharma and Ms.
Kamatchi M for their contribution to the study.
Conflict
of interest:The authors declare that they do
not have any conflict of interest. All authors have read and approved the
manuscript.
Author
contributions
1.
Maitrayee Senwas
involved in the conception and design of the work, analysis and interpretation
of data for the work, drafting of the manuscript and approving the final
version to be published.
2.
Luxitaa Goenka was
involved in the acquisition of data for the work, analysis and interpretation
of data for the work, drafting of the manuscript and approving the final
version to be published.
3.
Durga Jha was involved
in the acquisition of data for the work, analysis and interpretation of data
for the work, and approving the final version to be published.
4.
Vijay Raj was involved
in the acquisition of data for the lab work, analysis and interpretation of
data for the work, and approving the final version to be published.
5.
Soniya Charles was
involved in the acquisition of data for the lab work analysis and
interpretation of data for the work, and approving the final version to be
published.
6.
Kanchana Mala was
involved in the acquisition of data for the lab work analysis and
interpretation of data for the work, and approving the final version to be
published.
7.
Melvin George was
involved in the conception and design of the work, analysis and interpretation
of data for the work, drafting of the manuscript and approving the final
version to be published. Melvin George is also accountable for all aspects of
the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any
part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.
Impact
Statement
What
is already known on this subject?
Transthyretin has been
associated with the neurological development of fetus and it is down regulated
in the placental villous trophoblasts of early pregnancy loss in human.
Oxidative stress has been associated with many reproductive complications such
as infertility, miscarriage, pre-eclampsia, fatal growth restriction and
preterm labour.
What
the results of this study add?
The present study is in
consensus with the existing literature that measurement of total antioxidant
capacity could be a suitable diagnostic marker for EPL; however, the present
study failed to demonstrate relationship between plasma Transthyretin and early
pregnancy loss.
What
the implications are of these findings for clinical practice and/or further
research?
The supplementation of
antioxidants can prevent poor pregnancy outcomes. Future studies should be
directed towards understanding the role of transthyretin in early pregnancy
loss using a larger cohort of subjects.
References